American Duty: To Consume or To Give?

So, perhaps you're aware, but the US government is giving each of its tax paying citizens an Economic Stimulus Package. For me, this means $600 of seemingly free money. I don't begin to understand all of the economic ramifications of said money, but I do know that it creates a bit of a conundrum. Do you do what the government wants and spend it on 'stimulating' the economy? Or do you do something else with it like save it, or give it to charity?

I won't tell you what to do with yours (other than urge you to pray about it before you hop in the car to go buy a new iPod), but David Swanson over at Out of Ur, thinks churches should be talking about it and wants to know what yours is saying about the Package.

He's not necessarily advocating that your Stimulus be signed over to become your church's Stimulus, but at least asking that old chestnut, "WWJD?"
“I thought that spending my check from the government was supposed to be the patriotic thing to do, but I’m not sure it’s the Kingdom thing to do.” That is how my friend Chuck began explaining his idea about what our congregation could do with the economic stimulus payments that begin arriving in the mail this week. After hearing so much about the sluggish economy and our responsibility to jumpstart it through consumption, he was wondering if there might be a better way to invest Uncle Sam’s rebate.
On Sunday, I invited Chuck to join me in front of our church. I asked him to explain why spending the money on himself was not the best thing he could do with it. “As I read about the government’s plan in the news, the more the idea of spending money on myself seemed to be at odds with the values of God’s kingdom,” he said. He told us he’d been reading Jesus’ words in Luke 12 and it appeared to be opposed to the message that we can spend our way to prosperity, security, and happiness....
Hop over to Out of Ur to finish the article and chime in there if you want to let him know what your church is doing.

For ThinkChristian's part I'll ask you a few questions: have you thought about what you're going to spend it on? Anyone finding this money to be a godsend? Have you received your Stimulus Package yet? Other thoughts?

Login to comment

IMPORTANT Did you have an account on the old ThinkChristian.net site? Click here transition your account. This will sync all your comments with your email address.

Comments (4)

Here in Singapore we receive this packages on an almost yearly basis.
it ranges from $200 to about $600 a year depending on its purpose.

Most times it is to offset the taxes that the government has put in place for Goods and Services. i.e. when we purchase groceries, pay for tuition etc. the 2-3% increase in these taxes are offset by these grants in cash.

What do we do with it?

Well, after so many years here's what i do:
tithe 10% and save the rest. it is used to buy presents for people, and yes, sometimes myself.
Since this is income of a sort, it may be a good idea to give a little back to GOD in whatever manner you tithe (to your church, feeding the homeless, buying someone's groceries, paying someone's bills, etc.).

As for me, I do not plan on spending what remains on any kind of consumer goods. Grocery prices are increasing and my debt is not getting any smaller. So I'm going to keep it in the bank and use it to continue to buy groceries and pay my bills. And I guess I'll stash a bit for that rainy day.

...And they're not going to tax us on this next year, right? Because that would kind of defeat the purpose since I'm sure we won't be a better economic situation as a nation (and globally) in 8 months.

Does anyone really believe that putting this money into the pockets of Best Buy, Circuit City or Apple Stores is going to 'stimulate' the economy and get us out of this 'economic slump' which our president blames on the Congress?

You know how much hundreds of millions it costs each day to maintain this Iraq War?
We have a daughter who is in graduate school and not working due to class and schedule. We see this money as something we can use to make her life a little easier. With it she can pay rent, pay utilities and buy food. Then again she could use it to come and see her family for a visit. I'm all about family and how they can be together, so the money will not be spent by me so to say, but given to someone who can use it. God said to Love him and to love Jesus Christ. He also gave me three wonderful children and a wonder wife and friend of almost 38 years. I can't think of a better place to spend it than on them. In God's Grace John
Does everybody agree that people losing their jobs and homes through a prolonged recession is bad? That families entering into poverty is bad? Children going hungry is bad? Economists are trying to end the misery and many have proposed stimulous packages to shorten the recession. Whether you agree or disagree with the economic theory behind a stimulous, one good way of guaranteeing the doom of this well-intentioned effort is to get super-spiritual about it and take it out of the economy. Is God glorified by this recession being prolonged? Let's give this stimulous a chance to work.

See the latest in:

Promotion

promo 1 promo 2
promo 3 promo 4

Donate Now