Tomorrow will be a big day for Apple. The much sought after iPhone 4 will be available for pre-order. Millions of people are expected to buy the phone by the end of the year, but many may not stop to think about the human cost that goes into making the product.
There’s been plenty of news reports in the past month about the Chinese company Foxconn. Their workers receive low pay and are in assembly lines where they work extremely long hours. This year, there have been more than a dozen employees attempt to commit suicide because of the depressing conditions. (That number is below average suicide rates in the U.S. considering Foxconn employs hundreds of thousands of people.)
As a response to the criticism of working conditions, Foxconn has increased pay 66% (meaning workers will get around $300 US a month). Plus Apple has stepped in to give some profit sharing to workers as a bonus as well.
But Foxconn is much bigger than the iPhone itself. If I look at the technology my wife and I own or use at work, much of it has been touched by Foxconn. Here’s a list: 2 iPhones, an Amazon Kindle, my Dell laptop at work, an HP laptop at home, an iPad and a Nintendo Wii. Even if you don’t own any of these, you probably own something Foxconn manufactures. Beyond the list above, they work with Sony, Microsoft, Intel, Cisco, Motorola and Nokia.
I write all of this to ask, what’s the appropriate Christian response? It’s easy to say, “Don’t buy from these companies.” But the reality is we do. Go to any Christian conference and you’ll see iPhone’s and iPad’s everywhere. At work, you don’t really have a choice about what computer they give you. And are you really going to give up your iPod or cell phone. Chances are if they’re not made by Foxconn, they’re probably made by another company with similar working conditions.
It's equally as easy to turn the other way and say that lifestyles are different in China than in the U.S. Or say that factory work is tough or depressing anywhere in the world.
I believe in social justice, not because it’s a big church buzz word right now, but because every human should be treated well. I know in this case the right answer is not support any of these companies until working conditions improve. But I know the truth is I’ll get the next iPhone or some other gadget Foxconn makes. In some ways that makes me a little disappointed in myself.
I clearly don’t have a great answer for reconciling all of this. How about you? How do you respond?





Login to comment
Alternate Login
Use your social media account to login.
Login with your ReFrame account
Comments (9)
13 suicides would be big news if there were only 10,000 workers. But there are 330,000 at Shenzen. World Health Organization suicide figures for China (1999) are 13 males and 14.8 females per 100,000 people. Lets be conservative and say the average, especially because these are younger people, is 10 per 100,000. Just the Shenzhen Foxconn plant alone, with its 330,000 employees, would be expected to have about 33 suicides this year, or 14 so far. The humane environment of Foxcon is actually cutting the number of suicides.
Patrick Mattimore, a fellow at the Institute for Analytic Journalism comments that The larger problem stems from the fact that most journalists have not been taught to critically examine statistics. They follow the herd which often means that they report numbers without providing readers a context for making sense of those numbers..
Here's the link to Apples audit if you are interested http://www.foxconn.com/SER_Pub...
I would also add to Rickd comment that it is not only the media who lacks the discernment when viewing facts but also the general public. Individuals must make decisions for themselves. If you personally are convicted or just plain concerned, do your own research, pray, and reach a decision with the Lord's instruction. Sounds simple...because it is.
http://www.coyoteblog.com/coyo...
One morning, a rice farmer in southeast Asia might faces a choice. He can continue a life of brutal, back-breaking labor from dawn to dusk for what is essentially subsistence earnings. He can continue to see a large number of his children die young from malnutrition and disease. He can continue a lifestyle so static, so devoid of opportunity for advancement, that it is nearly identical to the life led by his ancestors in the same spot a thousand years ago.
Or, he can go to the local iPod factory, work long hours (but certainly no longer than he worked in the field) for low pay (but certainly more than he was making subsistence farming) and take a shot at changing his life. And you know what, many men (and women) in his position choose the FoxConn factory.
If we stop buying the products they manufacture, they may lay off those employees. How much worst can a person feel when they now have absolutely no income to provide for their families? Is almost like choosing the least of two evils.
Debra
presentufaultless.wordpress.co...
Quote: "If you stopped buying, things would be worse. Yes, we live in poverty, but poverty is worse without out you."
Stopping would increase the problem, not help. Using the Apple situation, with that relationship we have an inroad to help. If we were not there, we couldn't help at all. Like anything, this is a non-perfect and messy process.
This issue is similar to the fair-trade chocolate one. I firmly believe that if you choose to buy products where you are fully aware of the social injustices associated then you should be writing letters and using your western powers to lobby these organizations!
If you won't sacrifice buying the lasted technologies for self pleasure then sacrifice a few minutes in your life to write a letter and make great change.