Giordano Bruno, heretic and philosopher

Here's a bit of bizarre but fascinating church history for you: the New Yorker has a detailed overview of the life and death of Giordano Bruno, a sixteenth-century heretic burned at the stake by the Inquisition for his strange (and in some ways scientifically prescient) understanding of the cosmos. One of his basic ideas was that the universe was infinitely vast, a proposal which (along with his other unorthodox views) was seen as contradictory to the Church's belief that Earth and mankind were the central components of God's Creation:

Inconveniently, that vision was heresy from end to end. If there were countless worlds besides ours, this sidelined the Christian story. Creation, expulsion, salvation: such things might have happened, but somewhere off in a corner, while other things were happening on other planets. Also eliminated was God’s difference from humanity. If, as Bruno saw it, God was present in every atom of the universe, then transubstantiation became a silly idea. (God was already in the wine.) Ditto incarnation. Bruno later said that he started having doubts about Jesus at the age of eighteen; in his mature philosophy, the Messiah has no place. Nor does original sin, or pretty much any sin. God “makes his sun rise over good and bad,” Bruno wrote. Even devils were going to be pardoned. To lead a virtuous life, you had only to do unto others as you would have them do unto you. As the reader may have noticed by now, much of this constitutes liberal Christian thought in our time. (What Bruno discarded was the Church’s literalism—exactly what many of today’s believers have done.) Likewise, Bruno’s cosmology anticipated modern physics and astronomy. But it did not accord with the views of the sixteenth-century Church. It sounded like Protestantism, or worse.

He certainly was a character; he sounds like somebody straight out of an Umberto Eco novel. (As a matter of fact, my only other knowledge of Bruno comes from John Crowley's Aegypt novels, in which he is a central character.)

I mostly just wanted to pass this along to you because it's curious church history, but a thought occurs to me as I re-read this mini-biography: it's interesting how very seriously ideas were taken in Bruno's time; the theological implications of his ideas alone were enough to make him a threat. Ideas were perceived to have real power in and of themselves.

Anybody else have a "favorite" heretic from church history—somebody whose rebellion against orthodox Church beliefs fascinates you?

Login to comment

IMPORTANT Did you have an account on the old ThinkChristian.net site? Click here transition your account. This will sync all your comments with your email address.

Comments (4)

Am I the only one who thought that this was going to be a piece about the British Prime Minister?
Eddie, if I was being honest when I first saw Giordano, I thought of this great pizza place nearby me where I grew up.

That said, it's a really interesting story and always good to get a reminder that some philosophies have been around for quite some time.
Favorite all-time heretic: Some dude called Jesus of Nazareth - He ruffled a few feathers in his day!
Heresy, as Paul used the term, comes from a Greek root meaning faction or party. In a hierarchically organized church, or even a disorganized church with established doctrine, accusations of heresy are the party in power calling the parties out of power factions. Its not much different from the accusation of "factionalism" by whoever is in power in a communist party. The fact that there are parties at all, such as those of Apollo vs. those of Paul, is the error. When each individual can speak, and each individual listens to, is challenged by, learns from, or learns to reaffirm their own beliefs in response to, what others are saying, we have a true fellowship of believers, who are humble enough not to claim the mantle of God for the limits of their own understanding. Many Protestants, including Luther, Calvin, and Zwingli, would have been equally ready to burn Bruno at the stake.

See the latest in:

Promotion

promo 1 promo 2
promo 3 promo 4

Donate Now