Notes from an e-reader convert

In Gary Shteyngart’s futuristic and comic narrative about the upcoming demise of the United States, "Super Sad True Love Story," one of the signs of the Apocalypse is the fate of books.

You remember books. Those hefty artifacts of paper, glue and ink that we used to cart from place to place, wondering why we’d brought so many with us. Those things that used to thunk to our noses as we drifted off to sleep beneath their pages. Surely you remember them?

I still have a few around the place, but I did not have one in my hands as I was reading Shteyngart. I hardly know what to call his work in the form that I read it. Narrative doesn’t seem quite right, even though that’s what I called it above. But that doesn’t get at the substance of the thing. E-book? Document? It does exist in the archaic book format, but that’s not what I was using to read it. What do I call myself? A reader of e-reader files?

In Shteyngart’s ... e-story, the main character, Lenny Abramov, has a “Wall of Books,” something no one in his contemporary New York City environment values anymore. Anticipating the arrival of a much younger woman with whom he wants to connect, Eunice Park, he considers his collection:

“I counted the volumes on my twenty-foot-long modernist bookshelf to make sure none had been misplaced or used as kindling by my subtenant. 'You’re my sacred ones,' I told the books. 'No one but me still cares about you. But I’m going to keep you with me forever. And one day I’ll make you important again.' I thought about that terrible calumny of the new generation: that books smell. And yet, in preparation for the eventual arrival of Eunice Park, I decided to be safe and sprayed some Pine-Sol Wild Flower Blast in the vicinity of my tomes, fanning the atomized juices with my hands in the direction of their spines."

That musty smell of densely packed libraries - the scent track of so many of my intellectual and cultural awakenings - will soon be consigned to the dustbin of history. In its place will be the library of odorless glass and metal that is my smartphone. Our patience for outmoded technologies will grow thin. (Is there still a Society for the Advancement of Telegraph Usage?) Our facility with the digital will grow. And all those books that have been the symbol of the advance and preservation of civilization will look like IBM Selectric Typewriters in a room full of Macs.

Even so, I can’t write the panegyric to the printed text I thought I would be developing in response to the world of electronic reading devices. I read more now rather than less. I find myself discussing books and literature more. My vocabulary has grown because I can press on a word and a dictionary definition pops up to enlighten me.

But I still appreciate books. Next to me as I write this is a wonderfully bound Library of America volume of William Faulkner’s work with a cloth cover and red ribbon bookmark. It seduces me with the promise of a truly sensual pleasure. I will savor that book, its weight and its beauty and even its sound as it resonates when dropped on a table. I will savor it. I just hope I read it.

As a person from the community of The Book, I feel slightly treasonous in adapting to the virtual read so readily. But if the Word can be made flesh, it must be powerful and versatile enough to accommodate many platforms. The question is whether we can sit still with the Word long enough, whether in leather- or app-bound format, to let it form us. And despite the dystopian future Shteyngart sees, I am optimistic. Because books are not the "sacred ones.”

This piece originally ran in Catapult Magazine.

Login to comment

Comments (3)

Of course, the original written scriptures were not even books, but handwritten scrolls. Not books and chapters and verses in order, but a basket of loose writings in columns. I could imagine a nostalgic ancient blogger lamenting the loss of smooth lambskin parchments, scribal handwriting skills, and the serendipitous providence of reading something beautiful after grabbing the wrong scroll or rolling to the wrong column.

And now, my most productive method of Bible study is certainly in e-Bibles, where cross-references and insights give instant contexts for understanding.

Every technology has side-effects, good or ill. May the Story of God and His People always be told in every technology we can find.
Recently Eerdmans Publishers had on their FB wall a youtube film, "How to Open a Book" (aka "Learn the Book" by another poster), describing a similar scenario: the medieval scholar moving from parchment scroll to book, complete with medieval IT-guy taking him through the book, step-by-step . . . . fun stuff.
What I worry about with E-books and electronic media are the continual updates in tech, therefore making the previous mode not only obsolete but inaccessible---witness platters and reel-to-reel and 8-track and cassettes in the music industry; the devices themselves wear out; the tech to play them becomes a throw-away or a rare antique. All those CD's I have collected---yet the move now is to iTunes, downloads etc---and files get corrupted; how long a virtual shelf-life does electronic info have?
I know that books also corrupt and crumble---but I look in my collection and I have more than a few that are close to a century old, many that are my contemporaries in age and yet perhaps in better shape. My oldest is an early 1700's slim volume by a minor Brit poet---cover and pages in better shape than many of my 20th century books.
I absolutely agree that tech has astounding possibilities---a friend said she was able to take "a whole library" on vacation, all contained in her Kindle; back-lit devices eliminate awkward nightlights for late reading, etc, just to name a few basic advantages. One problem of concern-- will E-libraries with all their infinite storage capacity yet limit availability through their technology? Will libraries "purge" out-of-print or rare books without replacing them (or will the Gutenburg Project handle this mission)?
I'm not nostalgic for typewriters or telephones, but somehow I just can't see books in the same category as mere communication tools!
I don't think tangible books will ever go completely out of style. While I've seen a rise of Kindles, I have also seen a rise in people reading books (although no stats or data can back this 'hunch' up).

Predicting the end of something usually proves wrong, as we can see with the thousands of sci-fi movies and crazy preachers who thought we'd have blasted ourselves out of existence by now.

See the latest in:

Promotion

promo 1 promo 2
promo 3 promo 4

Donate Now