The stain that won’t go away

(BP oil spill as seen from space via NASA)

I’ve had more than a few people express intense psychological distress about the BP oil eruption in the Gulf of Mexico – and I live in the American Midwest, about a thousand miles from any physical hardship caused by the accident. Few times since 9/11 has a news event reverberated this profoundly in the minds of people who weren’t directly affected by it.

I think this mostly has to do with the fact that the story won’t go away. We live in a 60-second news cycle, in which most stories aren’t expected to last much longer than a tweet. No matter how horrible the details, the media always moves on.

Sure, we still mark the anniversaries of tough times. Indeed, the United States recently “celebrated” Memorial Day. But such actions look back on terrible events that have ended - that have been, as much as possible, cleaned up.

This oil story is literally spreading. It won’t go away, and each failed attempt to plug the spewing well at the bottom of the gulf only heightens our existential anxiety. We even watch a live feed from an underwater rover at the site of the spill and wonder, “What if it can’t be fixed?”

There might also be a deeper, spiritual reason why the BP disaster is so troubling. After all, I can’t think of a more apt metaphor for our own sin. This is a literal stain on God’s creation, one caused by humans and one we’re unable to erase on our own. Among many other things, this black blot is a constant, unrelenting reminder of our inherent fallen state.

You could also argue that we all bear some of the guilt – the sin isn’t only BP’s, but our own. Sure, much of our anger is rightfully directed at the petroleum giant – for putting the environment at risk in the first place and for responding to the crisis with what can best be described as corporate arrogance. Yet haven’t Americans – as a gas-guzzling nation – enabled this sort of indiscriminate oil lust? At one point do we look at our own energy consumption and realize that, in many ways, BP drilled in risky waters because we demanded it?

Considering the physical and mental distress the bursting well has caused, you have to wonder if God isn’t giving us another signal here. Pollution, climate change, oil-driven wafare, now this. Mounting evidence – much of it directly from nature, God’s frequent messenger – suggests that petroleum is no longer a viable source of energy. But instead of seriously investing in alternatives, we continue to gulp down the diminishing oil reserves left on Earth.

When they’re gone, things could get uglier than anything we’ve seen in the gulf.

Login to comment

IMPORTANT Did you have an account on the old ThinkChristian.net site? Click here transition your account. This will sync all your comments with your email address.

Comments (8)

The trouble is, we have invested a lot of time and money into investigating alternatives. The trouble is, they are under heavy fire by various special interest groups that aren't even related to oil.

The situation in the gulf is troubling, but the problem will get fixed one way or another.
Why aren't we investing in alternatives - could it be that the 'Quick Buck' is part of our western capitalist culture?
The Worlds media are still interested in this story because so many of us have oil rigs off our own shores, New Zealand has just last week given permission for another search on our pristine North East Coast!
Maybe B.P. in the U.S.A.has had a big accident- but does it compare to the deliberate bombing of Iraqui oilfields in the gulf war ?
A great, big "AMEN" to your last paragraph. I just don't get it. Do we, as a nation, really not see how desperately we need to find other alternatives to the greasy, brown stuff? What stops us? Oh wait, that would probably be the crispy, green stuff.
So where is the church's prophetic witness in this?

Why isn't the church calling on the nation to cut off its addiction to oil by changing our lifestyles? Why aren't churches prophetically calling their own members to live more sustainable lives? Why isn't there a movement within the church to bulldoze the acres of parking lots surrounding suburban churches or -gasp!- move out of the suburbs entirely and back into the cities?

This oil spill isn't just an environmental catastrophe - it's a slap in the face of God, who created a beautiful world and gave it to us to be responsible stewards. We in the church have tolerated, and often encouraged, the irresponsible and unsustainable American energy-hog lifestyle that leads to things like this; it is time that the church begin leading the culture to ways of living that are more in tune with an attitude of responsibility for the well-being of the planet.
This sounds like more of the self flagellation that goes on by those like the fellow who just went to China with Hillary Clinton and made constant comments about how we Americans are such bad people. Why is there such a funk over some portions of our population that drive them to do this? The oil stain will be gone in a few short years, along with the memory, just like the Alaskan oil spill. I know it was smaller, but the earth is very resilient, and this is not the type of stuff like dumping toxic waste in landfills that demonstrates unconscionable polluting. BP made some errors and took some short cuts, but not because I want to fill my tank at the station. They were trying to make more profit or someone was in a hurry to finish their part of a project. Bad, but not because of me. If you want to bring God into the equation how about trying on the 20 or 30 million babies aborted over the past 30 years? If God judged Israel for sacrificing their children to Molech and behaving like the world around them, choosing to trust the gods of their world (sound like us?) rather than the God who chose them for His own, do you think, maybe, He might just be majorly angry with us? Add up all the problems and situations we are, and have been, facing and it sure looks like a nation falling.
As sad as this event is, this only reveals another example of man's irresponsibility as stewards of what God has given us. I don't believe BP intended to dirty our shores with oil. But our constant thirst for oil created a demand that unfortunately created this mess. Everyone thought that Obama was going to fix our hunger for oil and help us adopt a different resource for energy. I learned today that he hasn't even met or spoken to BP's CEO about the issue. If only us American's were bold enough to stop using this source for our vehicles. What we need is a radical change and protest so these resources are replaced with better ones for us and our God given environment.
Given the severity of this oil spill (and I love that you minimize its environmental impact by saying it "will be gone in a few short years"... got documentation from a credible, nonbiased, and reliable source to back that claim up?), I don't think some self-flagellation is entirely out of line. In other words, given that American greed, selfishness, and irresponsibility caused this accident, it's not inappropriate that Americans feel some shame for the countless fish, birds, and other sea life - to say nothing of the livelihoods of hundreds of thousands of people - that are being devastated because we demanded more oil. As long as that shame leads to productive change - change that should be LED BY THE CHURCH - I'm all for it.

I also question any logic that refuses to place any blame on the incredibly wasteful, unsustainable, petroleum-slurping American lifestyle for an oil spill that's going to cause untold amounts of environmental devastation, but does see fit to place direct blame for the spill on abortion not being criminalized. Any logical system that rejects basic causality but retains such flimsy theological reasoning (backed up by rather irresponsible exegesis) is probably not to be trusted, and should probably be recalibrated.
Prophetic witness might be good. Barack Obama is only the president of the United States, and he is a pragmatic politician. He has been timid about taking bold steps, settling instead for incremental changes. In part, to be fair, he only has a 53% mandate. GWB deluded himself that that was substantial political capital, but its really a thin margin. Until a month ago, Obama thought he needed to concede some points on offshore drilling, in order to cobble together support for a half-way decent energy bill which would include a cap and trade system for carbon dioxide. If he wasn't always been accused of being anti-business and a covert socialist, maybe he'd take more risks to do the right thing, without compromise.

So, the church. There have been times when church revivals moved thousands or millions to abandon a lifestyle rife with profanity, drinking, whoring, or simply stealing (legally as well as illegally) from neighbors. Perhaps the fervor of a spiritual call to "Kick the oil habit" IS what it will take to inspire people to REALLY make life-changing decisions. (That doesn't have to be instead of, e.g., pointing out the sensible reasons for keeping sex within the embrace of marriage, but it would be a bold new call for the church).

See the latest in:

Promotion

promo 1 promo 2
promo 3 promo 4

Donate Now