‘Twilight’ and the agony of abstinence

Is anyone else confused by the fact that “Twilight” has been adopted by champions of abstinence?

Moral-minded critics and skittish parents have latched onto the literal fact that the teen lovebirds in the movie never actually have sex. Yet considering all the anguished panting and heaving going on, I’d say “Twilight” has things on its mind other than waiting until marriage.

For those who don’t know – meaning those who don’t have a teen or tween girl in their lives - “Twilight” is an adaptation of the first book in Stephenie Meyers’ romance series about a high-school girl who falls in love with her vampire classmate. He’s equally enamored with her, though in a confused way that mixes up emotional attraction, physical desire and basic animal hunger.

At least on the screen, “Twilight” is about nothing other than the fervent desire to engage in sexual intercourse - and the horrors that would result from indulging in such behavior.

From the first moment he sees new student Bella (Kristen Stewart), vampire Edward (Robert Pattinson) begins writhing in his seat as if some sort of uncontrollable urge has come over him. (To be frank, he looks as if he has to use the washroom.)

Not long after, Edward is swooping up behind Bella, sniffing her neck and whispering, “If you were smart, you'd stay away from me.”

This of course leads to the pair dating, which mostly involves her batting her eyes at him while he mumbles something along the lines of “I can’t ever lose control with you.” They almost do lose it, once, but to the relief of those critics and squeamish parents, they manage to stick to cuddling in their underwear.

With all of this going on, “Twilight” is simultaneously titillating and puritanical – sort of like listening to Barry White while taking a cold shower.

Unfortunately, religion can often be blamed for this sort of conflicted view of human sexuality, in which sexual desire is strictly defined as dangerous and evil. Indeed, Meyers – the creator of the “Twilight” phenomenon – is a Mormon, and while I can’t speak to how directly her religious background influenced her writing, I can say that her equating of sex and death isn’t that far removed from the sort of mindset that exists in some Christian circles.

Is there another way to look at things? In the movies, must sex always be the apple in the Garden of Eden?

I can think of one example in which it’s something different, from 2006’s “Away From Her.” Julie Christie and Gordon Pinsent play a long-married husband and wife dealing with the onset of Alzheimer’s disease, and the movie gives them a touching, affectionate moment of physical connection. Of course, a love scene involving two married retirees is not the sort of steamy sex Hollywood usually favors.

Can anyone else think of similar examples from other movies, in which sinless sexuality is something to be celebrated?

Login to comment

IMPORTANT Did you have an account on the old ThinkChristian.net site? Click here transition your account. This will sync all your comments with your email address.

Comments (7)

Related to the last comment of your article:
"When A Man Loves A Woman" -as I remember it- deals realistically, if not a bit over-the top, about married sexuality as a good thing and what it means to stand by your mate "for better or worse." Meg Ryan's real breakout role if you ask me. rr
Hrm... the first thing that comes to mind for me is a scene out of Rob Roy, where the eponymous character and his wife send the kids off and take advantage of the freedom imparted by kilts and skirts to have an open air quickie in a secluded spot outside of town.
I, for one, am not confused by the reaction to Twilight by the champions of abstinence. It's the same thing that happened with the movie Bella and the pro-life crowd. They're so wrapped up in their pushbutton issue that they totally ignore the conflicting message of the movie. For Bella, the pro-lifers completely ignored the fact that giving up your kid then trying to weasel your way back into her life as if nothing happened is NOT good parenting: it's selfish and harmful to your child. (At least, it was to my children when their mother did the same thing.)

WIth Twilight, the abstinence crowd is so enraptured with the apparent message that they, as you note, ignore the heart issue. "Cuddling in underwear" and engaging in deep emotional ties with a relative stranger are nearly on par with actual sexual intercourse when it comes to emotional and spiritual danger.
Hello,

I'm not a Catholic but maybe there are some who can correct me if I am wribg

Isn't there a Catholic idea of "An Occasion of sin"--I may be wrong about name, but as I understand it, doesn't it say you are to avoid situations where you would be tempted to sin?

I think that is the heart of what is being considered here.

Shouldn't we avoid situations where we would be tempted? It doesn't sound like that is what is being taught in that movie.

Cordially,,
C. Walker
I did not see the movie and most likely will not. To glorify vampires in any aspect seems a little funny to start with. To portray them as human, when they have been portrayed as the living dead is absurd. Why vampires, why not superboy and supergirl or maybe daffy and daisy. Yes I know it's just a movie, but to some tweens it is a lot more and as a grandparent of a tween, I would not want him to see this. What ever happened to Abbott and Costelo meet Dragula? In God's Grace John
I haven't yet seen this movie and don't plan to, but I have seen this book and it's sequels in the hands of teens even in my church. My question is, what about Jesus' assertion in the Sermon on the Mount that "if you look upon a woman to lust after her you have already committed adultery with her in your heart."? Isn't there sin in the heart going on in this film (and the books?) and should we as Christians be discouraging this? Are we not supposed to avoid even the appearance of sin to the world?
Excuse me, but is everyone forgetting that this is a 100 plus year old vampire hitting on a 16 year old girl?

See the latest in:

Promotion

promo 1 promo 2
promo 3 promo 4

Donate Now